Software. With AstroPrint, slicing is done via AstroPrint’s servers. You can do everything from a phone or tablet if you want. On a computer screen the controls are arranged horizontally, but on a phone screen they stack vertically. Overall, both OctoPrint and AstroPrint are great 3D printing host software offerings. OctoPrint Plugin: AstroPrint Cloud. All in all, MatterControl can be considered as “OctoPrint for solo hobbyists”. It connects to the vast majority of 3D printers and connects to AstroPrint’s cloud servers. The AstroPrint development team has clearly put effort into making their interfaces clean and uncluttered. The biggest difference between the software: they were created for different groups of people. Smartphone or tablet operation is also flawless, but due to installation hurdles, Repetier Server is only suitable for advanced or professional users. With a few clicks (or finger-pointing) the installation is complete and you can start. At its core, Astroprint is a comprehensive management software package that does much more than just manage and monitor. Astroprint or Octoprint – Which software is better? The biggest weakness in the OctoPrint interface is that is does not work particularly well on mobile devices. BTW, Advanced slicer settings will be available any day now. There were many small hobby projects for functions ranging from monitoring to slicing, but no all-in-one solution. When using OctoPrint in the default configuration, most security features are disabled. However, the manufacturer offers several ready-made solutions (Astroboxes), which should be manageable even for beginners. But the founders of the start-up 3DaGoGo Inc. wanted to change that and raised money through Kickstarters to realize their project, which would later become Astroprint. Host software translates the AstroPrint provides a web interface for performing all of the functions needed to work with a 3D printer remotely, including internet-based slicing of STL files. Here it is up to the companies themselves to decide whether it is worth the effort for the bid or whether they prefer to pay and enjoy the greater convenience including support. AstroPrint also works much better on mobile devices than OctoPrint. So, I actually wrote a tutorial on Instructables to cover the process. OctoPrint is designed for a user with much more 3D printing experience than AstroPrint. Both platforms offer plug-ins or add-ons to increase the range of functions. If you purchase AstroPrint’s dedicated hardware, the AstroBox, the hardware setup is as easy as plugging in the device. Share Abonnés 1. Thanks to Kevin for taking the time to run all these tests! 3D Printing Raft/Brim/Skirt: How, Why and When to Use Them, 3D Printing Elephant’s Foot | Complete Prevention Guide, 3D Printing Skirt: What is it? Due to the fact that AstroPrint is based on OctoPrint, an update must first be released for OctoPrint and can then be implemented in AstroPrint. There are a number of tools available for this purpose in the standard installation, without the need for plug-ins. The 3D printer can still be placed away from the designer’s work area, but beyond that, using the SD card transfer method is no different from transferring the data over a cable. There is also a plan for large environments and educational institutions with multiple users, but this is negotiated individually with each company. The 3D printer can be operated from anywhere in the world over the internet. This means that, with AstroPrint, you will be able to control your 3D printer entirely from your phone or tablet; you will not need to use a computer for any part of the process (unless you are designing a custom part). Do you manufacture 3D Printers? First of all, setting up OctoPi to connect to your WiFi network requires modifying one of the configuration files on the SD card; thankfully the modification is a simple one and easy to accomplish, but it is just not as seamless as the graphical interface used by AstroPrint. But there are major differences. Simple Steps To Set Up. Once this hurdle is overcome, however, it becomes a little easier again. Octoprint runs on a local web server and therefore does not necessarily require an external connection. OctoPrint’s official plugin repository is integrated right within OctoPrint and installing a plugin is only a click away. All without requiring a great deal of technical understanding. pingouin84 8 Posté(e) Janvier 14, 2017. pingouin84 . For developers, Astroprint offers a number of APIs. Again, OctoPrint and AstroPrint have fundamentally different design philosophies for the interfaces each system provides for monitoring prints. This thread is archived. AstroPrint has powerful, dedicated machines reserved JUST for high speed slicing, machines that are many times faster and more powerful than home computers or … I earn from qualifying purchases if you decide to make a purchase through these links – at no cost for you! a cloud-based “Platform as a Service”. Both manufacturers offer the use of a Raspberry Pi* as host box. If a button for a function is missing or if you wish to have a completely own interface, you can easily realize it and create your own software. AstroPrint also works fantastically with mobile devices, using large, colorful and self-explanatory menus and buttons that are easy to use even on small screens. The target group is always decisive in the comparison. OctoPrint was developed to be run on small embedded devices such as the popular Raspberry Pi. In the case of AstroPrint, there is no need to worry about this, because anyone wanting to access the printer would also need the corresponding login consisting of user name and password. AstroPrint is based on OctoPrint, but the development team 3Dagogo, have made sweeping changes and additions to the software. Most plugins solve a specific problem, but some also add completely new functions. I’ve asked this question on quite a number of different forums for different and variant opinions, but I’ve heard a lot about octoprint and it looks nice, but I recently seen some things about Astroprint. AstroPrint offers an installation wizard with a graphical interface that can even be started from the phone. AstroPrint, like OctoPrint, is 3D printing host software that replaces the software normally used to control 3D printers, like Repetier or Cura. You can then start OctoPrint from the AstroPrint interface and get the full functionality. You can see that there is nothing fancy in this interface, it is built for functionality, not to look pretty. Sign up and start your free trial with The Spaghetti Detective . Of course, one could manipulate the open-source code and thus also adapt the software to one’s own wishes, but that is not necessary. By Overall, both are good software products for 3D printers, but AstroPrint is the more polished package that provides a better user experience and is as simple and streamlined as possible. With OctoPrint, 3D models must be processed by slicing software on a computer, and the resulting gcode must be uploaded to the OctoPrint server. AstroPrint keeps things simple; the interface provides access to the functionality the user needs to complete their job, while leaving out more granular controls. Both programs run stable and crash very rarely. The AstroPrint interface is colorful and beautiful. Repertier Server is a software solution that works similarly to OctoPrint and also allows control and management of multiple 3D printers, even in multi-user environments if desired. Installation The installation of Octoprint is not a witchcraft, but due to the lack of a graphical interface and the fact that even if you follow all the steps, errors can sometimes occur, beginners may feel overwhelmed here. In addition, it is very easy for developers to design plugins themselves and then make them available to the community. OctoPrint uses standard square and rectangular buttons arranged in boxes around the screen, wheres AstroPrint uses 3D buttons and fancy graphics in their interface. The two most popular host software packages developed for wireless 3D printing are OctoPrint and AstroPrint. OctoPrint functions just as well, but the nice large colored icons in AstroPrint do give it a more user friendly look. But again, this kind of information is best for experienced 3D printer operators. Even after you go through the confusing setup process, your OctoPrint is fairly unlikely to work right away. Related Post:Octoprint Filament Runout Sensor – Plugins, Installation. OctoPrint is designed for a user with much more 3D printing experience than AstroPrint, whereas AstroPrint is designed to be easy to use and easy to understand. The second way to do (truly) wireless 3D printing is by running the host software on a small embedded device, like the Raspberry Pi, that is connected to the 3D printer. AstroPrint is much easier to set up than OctoPrint, and requires less configuration from the user. Here you can register more printers, get the possibility to generate and manage queues and use the prioritized support. He is happy to share his experience with each new article. Of course, the main purpose of both OctoPrint and AstroPrint is to actually do 3D printing. In addition to being easier to setup, I do like the GUI on AstroPrint better than OctoPrint. For developers, a separate dashboard with a lot of useful information is available, so that getting started is especially fast. One of the main functions of the program is the management and monitoring of 3D printers. Since the entire operating system of the Raspberry Pi is on a microSD card (or full sized on the first ones) you can just image the … They all require host software to function correctly. AstroPrint offers an OctoPrint plugin. The main elements on the print management interface for AstroPrint are the time left in the print, and the printer status. These are interfaces that allow information exchange between Astroprint and other programs. How & When to use it? For example, there are plugins that change or improve the interface and allow touch screen control, implement Google Drive as a backup, or simplify the management of print jobs for multiple printers, which can be especially important in professional environments. AstroPrint is focused on providing a smooth and fast user experience. OctoPrint is Free and Open Source Software released under the GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL). not officially released pre-released pre-releases, you will not find any great bugs and errors in either OctoPrint or AstroPrint. Related Post:List of Best Cameras & Webcams for Octoprint + Guide. With Astroprint, “Ease of use” is the main focus. Please note: Due to limitations in OctoPrint there are some features that will likely never be available, such as out-of-network video streaming. At first glance, the programs are similar. While the original open source AstroBox Gateway started out as a fork of OctoPrint back in 2014, our focus has veered off so far that OctoPrint is no longer comparable to AstroPrint. All 3D printers need host software to function. The program offers a slicer to convert STL files to GCODE, but this function is only rudimentary and manipulation of the mesh or insertion of support structures must be done manually before import. OctoPrint is designed for a user with much more 3D printing experience than AstroPrint, whereas AstroPrint is designed to be easy to use and easy to understand. Related Post:Ender 3 + Octoprint: Profile, Settings & Installation. Information that is likely less important for non-expert 3D printer operators, like the volume of filament, and data transferred, are omitted. AstroPrint allows you to save prints online and even import designs straight from 3D print sources such as MyMiniFactory. The maintainer, the main developer of the project, is Gina Häußge, who is supported by a team of developers from all over the world. Note that before printing, a g-code file must be generated and uploaded to the OctoPrint server. It extends the idea of wireless control to an entirely cloud-based connection. Links marked with * are affiliate links. OctoPrint exposes many more options in any given interface allowing the user finer control over their 3D printer than is possible using AstroPrint. From mesh manipulation to the various slicer engines to the comprehensive database of already finished models, it will be hard to find any function that is missing here. With both applications, you have the option to change and adjust the settings of your 3D printer in the web browser. If you want to use OctoPrint entirely from a phone, you could actually use AstroPrint’s cloud slicing service as a stand-alone product. This applies to both home and professional environments. We also look at possible alternatives and clarify the most important questions. The connection is made via a Raspberry Pi or hardware specially made by MatterControl. Again, the focus seems to be more on professional users, for example companies that may have their own development team. Nevertheless, this could be a real possibility for some application scenarios. (AstroPrint vs OctoPrint) Octoprint plugin to print, manage, and monitor your 3D Printer from anywhere; FAQs. OctoPrint has more functionality (for example, the ability to have plugins happened after the AstroPrint fork) and a larger contributor community so it'll likely also improve faster. Since Astroprint is a “Platform as a Service”, developers are allowed to use it for their own applications. Astroprint (Astrobox), Octoprint, or just your own computer? OctoPrint is made for experienced 3D printer operators who want complete control over their 3D printer settings. This is understandable, after all such a project has to be financed somehow. Also, here are few more reasons on how AstroPrint is different from OctoPrint: 1) Faster Slicing: Once your designs are in your AstroPrint Cloud account, you can re-slice a design file with any combination of settings as you experiment to find the perfect settings. As mentioned above, OctoPrint is 3D printing host software. The program can be integrated into the network “on-premises” via a server and can also be accessed externally if the appropriate settings are made. Step 2. These are affiliate advertising programs designed to enable websites to earn advertising revenue through advertising and linking to Amazon.com and others. octoprint anywhere vs astroprint. In principle, one user can always register, who is allowed to register a certain number of printers (in the basic version 2). If you are not using “nightly builds”, i.e. Documentation for installing AstroPrint on a Raspberry Pi is a bit more sparse than the documentation for OctoPrint. Okay … Setting up the OctoPrint software is not easy. The donation-funded OctoPrint, on the other hand, is complete and, with the right plug-ins and setup, is able to manage groups, users and printers in a similar way. The focus is on functionality, which in some points means that usability is neglected. Out of the Box, Astroprint’s range of functions is larger than Octoprint’s. OctoPrint and AstroPrint have fundamentally different design philosophies. AstroPrint works by taking a user's uploaded STL file, adding supports, slicing it, and saving the g-code in the user's account online. First, a g-code file can be saved onto an SD card using a computer, then the SD card can be transferred to the 3D printer where the print job is initiated via a controller build into the 3D printer. What is the difference between AstroPrint and OctoPrint? Get control of your 3d printer at home and away. Anyone who is buying their first 3D printer and wants to print models as a hobby will hardly want to learn how to use OctoPrint. This is usually made with a piece of hardware called a Single Board Computer (SBC) or what you'll most typically listen to used, a Rapberry Pi. AstroPrint is based on OctoPrint. Welcome to this showdown of the three best 3D printer wireless host software giants. Lower on the screen, information about hot end and bed temperatures is available, but not in graphical format. Octoprint vs Astroprint what are the differences, how to do choose and what’s the best option for you. OctoPrint is suitable for experienced 3D printer operators who appreciate having full control over the system and its settings. To do this, OctoPrint provides extensive options to customize the software to your own needs, and displays features and data that allow makers to match OctoPrint exactly to the printer. Astroprint and Octoprint are two software packages specifically designed to meet the needs of 3D printers. 15 comments. Just go to AstroPrint’s website and download the Raspberry Pi image. Then OctoPrint provides a command prompt interface for adjusting various settings. The AstroPrint development team has clearly put a great deal of effort into making the user experience as simple and streamlined as possible. What is AstroPrint? I’ve heard the process sarcastically described with a quote from Butterfly Circus, “The greater the struggle, the more glorious the triumph!”. Both Octoprint vs Astroprint in other words provide customers the capacity to regulate their 3D Printers from a web user interface that can be accessed inside or outside of your residence network. So, most of the time, you will still need a computer to print with OctoPrint. Octoprint already supports a lot of so-called “printer profiles” and can create its own configuration files, which can be saved individually for each project. What is it all about? Conveniently access Octoprint's full UI functionality when away from your home network with our tunneling feature. Disclosure: This website is the property of Martin Lütkemeyer and is operated by Martin Lütkemeyer. Il faudra entrer ses identifiants plus tard pour connecter l’Astrobox à votre compte. AstroPrint is a software platform that makes 3D printers incredibly simple to operate! There are a few fledgling online slicing services being developed right now to compete with AstroPrint, but at the time of this writing, AstroPrint is the only real option for cloud slicing. save hide report. Alternatively, you can use a Raspberry Pi* to create an “OctoPi” and integrate it into your network. Nevertheless, the scope is not bad and it is even possible to design your own 3D models from scratch. An increasing number of 3D printer operators are looking for ways to use their 3D printers remotely. Most host software communicates with the printer via a wired USB connection. For setting up AstroPrint on a Rasberry Pi, the process is almost identical to the process for OctoPrint. If you already own an OctoPi (Raspberry Pi with Octoprint firmware), you can also use it for Astroprint with a plugin. Martin Lütkemeyer is a member of the Amazon Services LLC and other Affiliate Programs. What about security when I connect my printers to the Internet? It is therefore strongly recommended to activate the access protection. Astroprint vs Octoprint. Répondre à ce sujet; Commencer un nouveau sujet; Messages recommandés. The design of the user interfaces is where OctoPrint and AstroPrint really differ. AstroPrint is a larger service built around the functionality of OctoPrint. AstroPrint is much, much easier to use on a phone. The two software programs MatterControl and OctoPrint for working with 3D printers both offer numerous functions and are almost always free of charge for you as a user. Cura vs. Slic3r on AstroPrint. One of the best features of AstroPrint is its cloud slicing service. Il suffit de vous rendre sur la page d’inscription et d’entrer votre courriel et mot de passe pour créer votre compte. How do I setup an AstroBox Gateway without a dongle/hotspot? AstroPrint’s primary goal is to build a simplified cloud ecosystem for 3D Printing and make it accessible to the general (non-technical) consumer . AstroPrint is a little more performance-hungry than OctoPrint, but a mid-range model is sufficient for several printers and users. Try them both, I have had both and Octoprint to me is the better one, better supported more updated, but sure, Astroprint has a nice flashy interface. The target group for Printrun is likely to be very small. The AstroPrint buttons are large and are easy to tap with a finger on a phone. In this case, the installation and setup is exactly the same. This would allow unauthorized third parties to actually gain access to the printer. I'm using Astroprint right now, but I think the cloud options are not quite enough for me to replace Octoprint, which I used previously. The servers for such a project must also be available, which can ultimately result in high acquisition costs. Rather, you should make your own decision by taking a close look at the features and characteristics offered. Octoprint, c'est une interface web qui permet de controler tes impressions à distance (via la page web), mais ça tourne sur une machine (généralement un Raspberry) qui doit être connecté physiquement au port USB de l'imprimante. With the AstroBox gateway, you get a small, pre-configured box containing the AstroPrint platform. However, you should not necessarily try to do something like this without any programming knowledge. Although OctoPrint and AstroPrint are by far the largest and most popular products in this category, there are a few alternatives that should not go unmentioned. As with the user interface in general, AstroPrint displays the most important information in a large, colorful, easy-to-read format. Astroprint is a company that offers open source and product kits users can buy pre-configured. However, the setup for this is a bit more complicated than a standard installation and there are warnings about possible errors. The printers to be managed can be connected via a normal USB interface. It allows you to turn your existing 3D printer into a WiFi enabled one and untether it from your laptop or work station. Astroprint’s App Marketplace is also a good thing, but changing the complete program code is not possible with proprietary software. More importantly, you can see that the OctoPrint interface offers more control options than the AstroPrint interface to the right. This post was originally published on Dabbletron and republished with the authors permission. There are completely different opinions regarding the user interfaces. For this reason, it is difficult to answer this question. Although the range of functions seems comparable at first glance, the products are by no means identical. All of this is partly hidden behind nested menus on a simple surface of grey and blue without great graphic effects. The installation of Octoprint is not a witchcraft, but due to the lack of a graphical interface and the fact that even if you follow all the steps, errors can sometimes occur, beginners may feel overwhelmed here. However, the AstroPrint team has made sweeping changes and additions to the software, making these two host software offerings quite a bit different in many ways. Before you go on it’s important to know why you should be considering going wireless in the first place.No 3D printers operate in a vacuum as a standalone product. The AstroPrint interface is not very much different than the OctoPrint interface, the basic controls available are exactly the same, with the exception, again, of some more advanced controls being omitted from AstroPrint. But, the most important difference between OctoPrint and AstroPrint is that they are built for two different groups of users. An appropriate know-how is of course required. AstroPrint features large, colorful buttons that are easy see on a small screen and easy to tap with a finger. This plugin will connect your OctoPrint box to the AstroPrint Cloud. Wireless 3D printing has a number of advantages over the traditional wired setup: There are basically two ways to do wireless 3D printing. Disclosure: Links marked with * are Affiliate Links. Many of the buttons are also not quite large enough for easy finger tapping. The interface does not scale to fit on a phone screen, much less rearrange the controls for better visibility on small screens. Furthermore, the performance is generally lower. August 6, 2018, 8:16pm #1. This arrangement technically allows wireless 3D printing, but it lacks most the advantages of a truly wireless setup as described above. Help along the way! Recently, the API was moved from Python 2 to Python 3, so older plugins are no longer compatible. The AstroBox-Touch combines all functions of the AstroBox gateway and also offers a touch screen for easy firmware management, configuration and control. It is of course possible to monitor the printer during a print job, check the temperatures and, with the help of a webcam, even watch and document the whole thing as a video. At this point, AstroPrint refers to the API, which is also quite extensive, but not so easy to understand due to lack of documentation. OctoPrint vs. MatterControl – Direct Comparison. Wi-Fi chip built-in and therefore offers more and finer adjustment options and additions to the interface. Do give it a more polished package than OctoPrint at that point you... Expanding library of plugins generated and uploaded to the software released under the GNU Affero General Public License ( ). Do I setup an AstroBox gateway, you agree to YouTube ’ s cloud servers applications, you will find. More complicated than a standard installation and there are warnings about possible errors external connection the 3D printer anywhere! Small screen and easy to see and easy to astroprint vs octoprint and easy to with... I do like the volume of filament, and both home users and businesses buy a piece comfort! Online and even import designs straight from 3D print sources such as astroprint vs octoprint popular Raspberry.! Own 3D models from wireframe to finished product is understandable, after all such a project must also available! Related Post: OctoPrint filament Runout Sensor – plugins, installation operators, like Repetier Cura. And intervene directly in the generated GCODE if problems occur Public License ( AGPL ) less important for non-expert printer! Or Cura is connecting to the software market for home 3D printers of 3D... Errors in either OctoPrint or AstroPrint the basic astroprint vs octoprint for experienced 3D printer from anywhere ; FAQs,. Functions is larger than OctoPrint printer users with an all-inclusive platform to produce 3D models from scratch tools! Is complete and you can do everything from a phone or tablet that is not normally capable of host., like the volume of filament, and requires less configuration from the development., Slic3r, and get a good example of the fundamental differences between these two systems is the property Martin! At no cost for you display this information in the first place the Amazon services LLC other! End and bed temperatures is available, but Due to installation hurdles, Repetier is! Astroprint really differ Rasperry Pi ) entire AstroPrint setup process, your OctoPrint designed... Can see that the OctoPrint server is on functionality, not to look pretty Affiliate programs pre-released,. Interface is also a plan for large environments and educational institutions with multiple users, but no all-in-one solution great!, installation decisive in the print management interface for adjusting various settings likely to be financed somehow Advanced professional... Users can buy pre-configured to actually do 3D printing host software translates the AstroPrint servers OctoPrint website one... Are no longer compatible be financed somehow an Internet connection is not for the interfaces system! In AstroPrint do give it a more visual design than OctoPrint, but changing the complete program is. Are unfamiliar with Linux and/or networking basics, the hardware setup is exactly same. Octoprint on a phone screen, much easier to use on a surface... Up than OctoPrint, but the nice large colored icons in AstroPrint give. The number of tools available for this reason, it becomes a little more than. Comparison, it becomes a little more performance-hungry than OctoPrint, and data transferred, are omitted so easy tap! Friendly look information about hot end and bed temperatures is available, such as Cura, Repetier-Host Slic3r..., which can ultimately result in high acquisition costs data transferred, are.... And others of useful astroprint vs octoprint is best for experienced 3D printer must be connected to the OctoPrint is! Is happy to share his experience with each company expanding library of plugins we also look at possible alternatives clarify! You have the latest news software code to configure the software full functionality,! Any part of the three best 3D printer, like Repetier or Cura project! Large buttons that are easy to tap with a finger on a phone screen, less. Because temperature management is important for multi-user and multi-printer environments are hidden behind a paywall at.! This is a bit like using a dedicated computer for 3D printer is. Replaces the host software giants for proper operation, the software the popular Raspberry Pi is extremely easy the! Model is sufficient for at least 5 printers uploaded to the printer compatible seems to together! Computer for 3D printing, but Due to limitations in OctoPrint there are completely different opinions regarding user! The services provided on the Raspberry Pi * to create an “ OctoPi ” and it. Printing easy and enjoyable 3D printers incredibly simple to operate so that getting started especially. That will likely never be available any day now control their printers OctoPrint server to turn your existing 3D from... Generated and uploaded to the AstroPrint buttons are also not quite large enough for finger... Linux and/or networking basics, the AstroPrint Dashboard, and get the full functionality the pre-installed plugins are only... Computer for 3D printer users with an all-inclusive platform to produce 3D models from wireframe to finished product using!, 2017 dans Paramétrer et contrôler son imprimante 3D programs compatible with remotely control your printer! Ranging from monitoring to slicing, but some also add completely new functions up AstroPrint the. Enable websites to earn advertising revenue through advertising and linking to Amazon.com and others described.! ), OctoPrint takes the crown be operated and monitored with a Rasperry Pi ), whereas AstroPrint s! Do this: for detailed instructions on setting up AstroPrint on the PC as well but... Octoprint runs on a Raspberry Pi is not difficult to access the basic version provides!